top of page
Search

The Real Problem With Homework (That No One Wants to Admit)

Updated: 1 day ago


We have a fundamental misunderstanding of homework.


And it’s costing kids more than anyone realizes.


The model we’re operating from is simple:


The student understands the material → they go home → they complete the work → they turn it in.

Clean. Logical. Completely disconnected from reality.


Because that model assumes something that is not true—especially for kids with ADHD, autism, or PDA profiles:


  • That homework is one task

  • That success comes down to effort

  • That if they can do it, they will do it


No.


That’s not how this works.



Homework Isn’t a Task. It’s a System.


When you say “do your homework,” what you’re actually asking a child to do is execute a multi-step, high-level cognitive process across time, environments, and internal states.


To complete one assignment, they have to:


  • Catch instructions in a fast-moving classroom

  • Decide what actually matters

  • Write it down accurately

  • Remember it exists hours later

  • Start something they don’t feel like doing

  • Figure out where to begin

  • Stay focused when their brain is already tired

  • Work through confusion without support

  • Finish it

  • Get it back to school

  • Remember to turn it in at the exact right moment

  • Track everything else that’s due


That’s not responsibility.


That’s executive functioning at a very high level.


And here’s where most people get it wrong:


👉 This system is not just state-dependent

👉 It is also skill-dependent



Let’s Be Clear About That


These kids are not just struggling to access these skills.

In many cases?


👉 They are still developing them.


We’re talking about:


  • Task initiation

  • Planning

  • Organization

  • Working memory

  • Time awareness

  • Emotional regulation

  • Flexibility

  • Self-monitoring


These are not personality traits.


They are developing neurological skills.


And in ADHD, autism, and PDA?


-They can develop differently

-They can develop more slowly

-And they can collapse under stress



So Now We Have Two Problems—Not One


  1. Even when the skill exists, it may not be accessible under stress

  2. In some areas, the skill isn’t fully built yet


And we’re expecting both to function perfectly… at the end of the day… with little or no support.


That’s not a reasonable expectation.


That’s a setup.



By the Time Homework Starts, They’re Already Done


Let’s talk about what happens during the school day.


These kids are spending hours:


  • Managing constant demands

  • Navigating social dynamics

  • Filtering sensory input

  • Masking to meet expectations

  • Operating in environments with very little autonomy


Even when they look “fine,” they are:


👉 Working incredibly hard just to hold it together


That effort is invisible.

But it’s real.

And it’s exhausting.


By the end of the day:


  • Their nervous system is taxed

  • Their executive function is depleted

  • And the skills we’re asking them to use?

    👉 Are the first things to go offline



So What Are We Actually Asking?


We think we’re asking:

“Can you do your homework?”

What we’re actually asking is:

“Do you have these skills fully developed—and can you access all of them right now, after a full day of demand, with little or no support, under conditions that reduce motivation and increase stress?”

And for a lot of kids?

👉 The answer is no.


Not because they don’t care.

Not because they’re lazy.


But because:

👉 The system required to do the task is not available



Neurodivergent Brains Are Not Doing Less—They’re Doing More




Here’s another piece people miss entirely.

These kids are not processing less.


👉 They are processing more.


More sensory inputMore social informationMore environmental dataMore internal experience


They are not “tuning out.”


They are often:

taking in far more than most people can even perceive

This is why they function more like:


*Funnels, not filters


They’re not missing information.

They’re managing more of it.


All at once.

And that matters.


Because:

👉 More input = more load

👉 More load = more energy required

👉 More energy required = less capacity left for executive functioning


Now layer that onto a system where the skills are still developing.

And you start to see the problem clearly.



Stress Doesn’t Just Make It Harder—It Shuts It Down


This isn’t theoretical.


When stress increases:

👉 The prefrontal cortex goes offline


That’s the part of the brain responsible for:

  • planning

  • attention

  • impulse control

  • working memory


So when a child is overwhelmed and you say:

“Just sit down and focus”

You’re asking them to use the exact system that is currently not accessible.


And again:

👉 The less developed the skill, the faster it disappears under stress



PDA: When Demand Feels Like Threat


For some kids, demand doesn’t feel like pressure.

It feels like threat.


Not metaphorically.

Neurologically.


Demand avoidance is linked to:


  • anxiety

  • threat response

  • loss of autonomy


So what you see as:

👉 avoidance

👉 refusal

👉 “won’t do it”


Is often:

fight, flight, or freeze


And in those states?

Access to skill drops even further



The Hidden Load Is the Whole Story


All day long, these kids are managing:


  • transitions

  • expectations

  • social complexity

  • sensory input

  • pressure


They are using executive function just to get through the day.


Not to build skills.

Not to deepen learning.


Just to cope.


So by the time homework shows up?

👉 There is very little left.


And the skills we expect them to use?

👉 Haven’t had the conditions needed to grow.



What Homework Actually Demands


Let’s stop pretending this is simple.


Homework requires:


Cognitive Skills

  • understanding

  • recall

  • application


Executive Function

  • starting

  • planning

  • organizing

  • holding information

  • staying focused

  • shifting when stuck

  • managing time

  • checking work


Emotional Regulation

  • handling frustration

  • staying engaged

  • tolerating stress


Motivation

  • working without urgency, interest, or reward


That’s not one demand.

👉 a full neurological load.


And again:

These are developing skills being asked to perform under stressed and depleted conditions



And When It Falls Apart…


What you see:

  • “I forgot”

  • “I’ll do it later”

  • shutdown

  • frustration

  • avoidance


What’s actually happening:


They can’t access the skill

Or the skill isn’t fully built yet

Or both


Most of the time?

👉 It’s both.



This Is Where We Get It Wrong


We respond with:


  • more pressure

  • more reminders

  • more consequences


Because we think:

👉 “They just need to try harder”


But effort doesn’t build a skill that isn’t there.

And pressure doesn’t restore access to a system that’s offline.


What Happens Over Time


If nothing changes:


Short term

  • inconsistent performance

  • after-school meltdowns

  • growing frustration

Medium term

  • avoidance increases

  • stress builds

  • confidence drops

Long term

  • burnout

  • disengagement

  • identity becomes “I can’t”

  • massive gap between ability and output


And the hardest truth?

👉 The skills never fully develop—because the conditions never support them



The Bottom Line


This is not a compliance issue.

It’s not a motivation issue.

It’s not a character issue.

This is a capacity + skill development issue.

We are asking kids to perform using:

  • systems that are state-dependent

  • skills that are still developing


Under conditions that:

👉 reduce access

👉 increase stress

👉 and prevent growth



So Ask a Better Question


Not:

“Why aren’t they doing the homework?”


But:

👉 “What does this child need to access these skills—and what do they need to actually build them?”


Because until we answer that?


We’re not solving the problem.


We’re reinforcing it.



The Research Behind This


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
The Complete PDA Protocol

A personal message and a new way forward for families living with PDA If you’re reading this, there’s a good chance you’re exhausted. Not just tired—but worn down from trying everything you were told

 
 
 
PDA and Burnout

What is PDA PDA  is known as Pathological Demand Avoidance or Persistent Drive for Autonomy in more affirmative social models is a...

 
 
 

Subscribe For Updates!

Thanks for submitting!

720-209-8797

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

©2022 by Stephanie Kroack

bottom of page